Carbon Offsets alone are not enough

Every day, more people and organisations demonstrate their recognition of the climate crisis by committing to become ‘Carbon Neutral’. The first and most important part of that process is to reduce your carbon footprint as much as possible, usually by:

  • minimising air travel
  • buying locally produced food, preferably not red meat
  • insulating your home

Switching from a petrol/diesel car to electric or hybrid is also worth considering but the benefit depends on your mileage and the useful life of your existing vehicle.

However, unless you are growing all your own food, only using your own supply of renewable energy and not using motorised transport, you will inevitably still end up causing emissions of greenhouse gases. To become Carbon Neutral you need to offset this residual amount by buying offset certificates and then cancelling them (so they can’t be used twice).

The market for carbon offsets is unregulated, so it inevitably attracts fraudsters and incompetents. It also encourages corporates with large footprints, such as airlines, to offer massively under-priced solutions to try to minimise the scale of the problem.

You need to have confidence that your offsets are genuine and that they will be cancelled after purchase. Typically this means buying them through a quality assurance organisation, such as Gold Standard or Verra, or using a reputable intermediary such as Climate Impact Partners or South Pole.

None of the popular offsets actually remove carbon from the atmosphere. They are based on reducing emissions, often by supplying more efficient methods for heating and cooking to communities in Africa or Asia. Other programmes are intended to reduce the destruction of rainforests by providing financial incentives for local communities – a laudable objective but often difficult to measure in terms of impact and of course vulnerable at any time to being defeated. This article in The Guardian paints a worrying picture.

Although the cost of offsets has increased sharply over the past 12 months, it remains well below the price of carbon on the more widely traded markets used by companies to offset their emissions. Offsets are generally priced in the range of £10-20 per tonne compared with over £80 for the latter. The average UK resident is estimated to have a footprint of 14 tonnes, so a price of £20 would suggest that it is possible to offset all of the harm for less than £280. This just doesn’t seem realistic and indicates that the price of offsets is still too low.

If you really want to ease your environmental conscience, my suggestion is to base your budget cost on the wholesale price. So if your footprint is 20 tonnes, aim to spend at least £1,600. Use about 25% of that to buy high quality offsets and the balance to support charities that are seeking to achieve structural change in environmental behaviour and/or helping to encourage the development of new technology. Some of our favourites in this sector include:

ClientEarth – a legal practice run as a charity which has successfully won cases against governments and large multinationals

Carbon180 – a US charity which is encouraging carbon removal solutions.

Clean Air Task Force – another US charity that is encouraging the development of technology and practices that reduce emissions

All three of these charities are included in the Tythe Climate Action portfolio.

Other Articles
Education News Selection
Giving is Great scoops award for Best Philanthropic Initiative

We are extremely proud to announce that Giving is Great has won the 'Philanthropic Initiative Award' at the WealthBriefing Wealth for Good Awards ceremony in…more

A Better Way for Government to Fund Charities

Government spending on charities is highly significant for both parties but the way in which it is allocated is far from optimal. In this article…more

Overcrowded Prisons

The UK has a higher proportion of the population incarcerated than any other country in Western Europe. Moreover, overcrowding in prisons means that the scope…more

How do Giving is Great Ratings work?

Our unique algorithm analyses the digital data available on each charity in order to identify areas of strength as well as those that require further…more

Environmental charities really can make a difference

It's easy to become disillusioned at the scale of the environmental crisis that we are facing and the seeming reluctance of governments to coordinate responses.…more

How much of my donation actually goes to charity?

If you are considering what charity you should donate to, this is probably the question you want to ask, but the answer should not drive…more

What are the tax benefits of donating to charity?

Donations to charity are tax deductible in most cases, so it's important to make full use of them. Most people have heard of Gift Aid.…more

Which areas of philanthropy are most effective?

The text of this post is taken from an article on the Effective Altruism forum. It suggests that you can achieve the most impact by…more

Running out of time to save our planet

Although the latest IPCC report has a few encouraging data points, you can't get away from the overwhelming likelihood that, barring a miracle or an…more

What is the Disasters Emergency Committee?

The Disasters Emergency Committee ("DEC") is a registered UK charity that acts as an umbrella fund raising organisation for 15 large charities. It was originally…more

EQ Foundation is Money Marketing Charity Champion

We were delighted to win this award and the accompanying comments: "The judges were impressed by this submission for Charity Champion of the Year from…more

Effective charities and their impact

The best charities can be more than 100 times more effective than others so it pays to be selective. Giving is Great can help you…more

A Guide to Charity Volunteering

Helping others fulfils a deep need in our souls and usually results in a feeling of connection and self worth. There are tens of thousands…more

Tythe’s Climate Action Charity Portfolio

The G7 summit in Cornwall has helped to remind us that averting catastrophic climate change is a massive challenge, requiring concerted efforts by all of…more

Our Top Tips for Philanthropy

Here are some ideas to help you gain more satisfaction from your philanthropy and confidence that the causes you have selected are impactful. Engage your…more

Pros and Cons of Matched Giving

Double your donation is generally how the message goes. If you give £10 to a certain charity another party will add the same amount. Sounds…more

Making charitable bequests in Wills

Many people make bequests to charities in Wills, partly because it can be highly tax efficient but to make best use of these incentives there…more

What is Effective Altruism?

In this article we explain the basics of Effective Altruism, which seeks to combine the instincts of our hearts to support charitable causes with hard…more

How to become a Philanthropist

In this Blog we outline a strategy to help people who are new to philanthropy and for those who feel dissatisfied with the impact they…more


Giving is Great